I met Scotty from Scotty O Hotty at Kroger like 2 years ago. Nice dude that makes a kick ass hot sauce.
Papa Turts is also good stuff, made in Michigan. Smoked pepper has good flavor, not a ton of heat. So Hot It Hurts is good, reasonable heat.
Lots of people in the Ypsi/Ann Arbor area have a huge boner for Clancy's Fancy but I don't really get it. It's not bad, but it's also not stellar.
I've got a guy at work who makes his own hot sauce that is unbelievable. I can talk to him and see when he is making another batch and see if I can snag you a bottle (since you are almost my neighbor now it would not be difficult to drop it to you). His last batch blew my face off but had amazing flavor...mango, pineapple, habanero, and Carolina reaper...