> frank dadog Wrote:
> -------------------------------------------------------
> > Thomas TPRF Wrote:
>
> > -------------------------------------------------------
>
> > Is there an advantage of a thermoresister over a thermocouple?
>
> Accuracy. The resistor is fixed where thermocouples work on a
> differential. So thermocouples rely much more on calibration for
> accuracy. That being said thermocouples are the probe of choice, being
> cheap and having an extremely wide operating range depending on which
> type you choose. I don't think you can even get a thermistor that
> operates at head temps. Thermocouples are good from hot water to hot
> lava.
no way, any thermocouple will read exactly the same as long as it's made properly and the alloying is correct.
true that thermistors wont go to head temps, they also dont have the range. theyre really accurate but not over a wide range. the third option and probably actually what the trailtech's using are RTD which measures temperature dependent resistance changes. it would also explain why they use ultra tiny wires. probably some precious metal or PM alloy?
but thermocouples are a temperature dependent voltage created by two metals in contact, there's lotsa things that can make em go off in readings, especially changes to resistance in the wiring, or external voltages (I expect however that the erratic readings when running are from inductance from the plug wire rather than part of the spark charge)
they all get thrown off with varying lengths of wire, but thermocouples least so.
I actually don't know a whole lot about thermocouples but i use them for tons of stuff almost daily, i even got a chart of millivolt vs temperature for different thermocouple types as a ready reference taped to the wall next to my desk.
I once tried to use a thermocouple welder to reconnect 2 leads of the end of a trailtech, and it didnt work at all, so that'd also support it being a 2 wire RTD type of thing.